UK shoppers skepticism stems from the belief that original prices are manipulated to artificially inflate the perceived value of the discounts, thus casting a shadow of doubt over the true savings being offered.
(Image Source)
GLORetail Week’s recent investigation into the matter has brought to light a prevailing sentiment among the majority of British consumers regarding supermarket loyalty pricing – a sentiment tinged with skepticism and suspicion. According to an exclusive study conducted by Walnut Unlimited for Retail Week, a significant 59% of shoppers harbor doubts about the authenticity of discounts offered through these loyalty schemes. This skepticism stems from the belief that original prices are manipulated to artificially inflate the perceived value of the discounts, thus casting a shadow of doubt over the true savings being offered.
(Image Source)
Delving deeper into the findings, it becomes evident that consumer confidence in the value proposition of loyalty prices is lukewarm at best. Merely 56% of respondents feel that these loyalty prices genuinely offer good value for money. Furthermore, the proliferation of loyalty schemes has led to a perplexing landscape for consumers, with more than half expressing difficulty in discerning which retailer truly offers the best value amidst the sea of discounts and promotions.
The controversy surrounding supermarket loyalty programs gained significant traction last autumn when allegations surfaced regarding the employment of dubious tactics by some retailers to enhance the allure of their membership prices. These tactics, it was claimed, often resulted in negligible differences between member prices and general recent prices, or those offered by competing supermarkets. In response to mounting concerns over the fairness and transparency of these pricing strategies, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) announced in January its decision to launch a comprehensive review.
The CMA’s review aims to address the pressing issue of affordability within the grocery sector by scrutinizing the practices of loyalty pricing schemes. Specifically, the investigation will delve into whether consumers are being misled by the promotional offers, whether certain demographic groups are disproportionately disadvantaged by these schemes, and the broader impact of loyalty programs on consumer behavior.
Given the magnitude of these findings and the implications for consumer trust and loyalty, an interim report on the progress of the CMA’s inquiry is eagerly awaited, with an expected release date slated for July 2024.
In light of these developments, Amy Nichols, research director at Walnut Unlimited, underscores the imperative for supermarkets to conduct a thorough examination of why many British families perceive loyalty schemes as falling short in delivering genuine value. Nichols points out a subtle yet significant shift in consumer perception – from viewing loyalty programs as mechanisms for rewarding loyal patrons to mere conduits for accessing discounted prices. This transition, she suggests, could potentially undermine the trust and loyalty of customers who harbor doubts about the authenticity of the discounts being offered, thereby exacerbating loyalty issues among previously dedicated shoppers.
Source: Retail Week
